Post-traumatic stress disorder and children and adolescents from refugee backgrounds

CALD Child and Adolescent Mental Health Resource

eCALD Supplementary Resources

Young people from refugee backgrounds are vulnerable to experiencing poor mental health. The experiences of forced migration, trauma, grief and loss, and resettlement can result in young people being particularly at risk of developing mental health problems (Colucci, et al., 2014; Centre for Multicultural Youth (CMY), 2015). Additionally, many parents from refugee backgrounds have undiagnosed mental health conditions due to their refugee experiences (CMY, 2015). Research indicates that young people from refugee backgrounds (CMY, 2014; 2015):

  • Have a higher risk of depression, anxiety and PTSD than other populations of young people.
  • Are at risk of social isolation, and poverty due to family financial pressures.
  • Experience educational barriers due to a lack of or disrupted previous schooling.
  • Have high levels of fear for family members left behind.

Colucci et al. (2014) suggest that there are higher rates of psychiatric disorders amongst young people from refugee backgrounds, compared with the adult population, although there are lower than expected numbers of young people from refugee backgrounds presenting to mental health services.

Refugee children and adolescents face the same issues of cultural adaptation and intergenerational conflict as migrant children do (Hyman, Vu & Beiser, 2000). They are also vulnerable to the effects of the refugee experience pre-migration, most notably exposure to violence, trauma and loss. Refugee groups who have had extended trauma experiences; as well as unaccompanied or separated children and adolescents, have higher psychological risk than others (Ministry of Health, 2012). A number of risk and protective factors either moderate or exacerbate poor psychological health including: family cohesion, parental psychological health, individual dispositional factors such as adaptability, temperament and positive self-esteem, and environmental factors such as peer and community support (Stevens & Vollebergh, 2008). Children are also vulnerable to the intergenerational transmission of trauma. Many refugee children and young people in the first and second generation experience mental health difficulties, including PTSD, depression, anxiety and grief (Weine, 2008). First- and second-generation children born to refugee parents with PTSD are more vulnerable themselves to PTSD and other psychiatric disorders (Weine, 2008).

Refugee children are often reluctant to discuss past traumas and choose to focus on the future. This should not be discouraged because a future-orientated view has been associated with lower rates of depression in refugees (Beiser & Hyman, 1997). Factors which have been found to be protective in minimising psychological distress in children and young people are social and peer support from their ethnic communities, and the well-being of their parents (Weine, 2008).

The following table identifies the effects of trauma on children and young people from refugee backgrounds.

The effects of trauma on children and young people

(Ministry of Health, 2012)

There is growing evidence that children and adolescents experience a psychological reaction to trauma not dissimilar to that found in adults (Refugee Trauma Taskforce of the National Child Traumatic Stress Network (NCTSN), 2005). This may manifest itself in children in a number of ways including:

  • Withdrawal, lack of interest and lethargy.
  • Aggression, anger and poor temper control.
  • Tension and irritability.
  • Poor concentration.
  • Repetitive thoughts about traumatic events.
  • Physical symptoms such as poor appetite, overeating, breathing difficulties, pains and dizziness.
  • Regressions (for example, return to bedwetting).
  • Nightmares and disturbed sleep.
  • Crying.
  • Nervousness, fearfulness and proneness to startling.
  • Poor relationships with other children and adults.
  • Lack of trust in adults.
  • Clinging, refusing to go to school.
  • Hyperactivity and hyper-alertness.
  • Repetitive, stereotypical play.
  • Selective mutism.

Engaging with children and adolescents from refugee backgrounds and their families

The practitioner’s interest in learning about their client’s culture and religious background, and how the young person relates to their own cultural and religious identity is important (Valibhoy et al., 2015). It is important that professionals understand that young people from migrant and refugee backgrounds are often in the process of developing ‘multi-faceted identities’, “reflecting their exposure to varied environments and ways of life during their refugee or migrant journeys, at critical development stages” (Valibhoy et al. 2015).

Although ‘refugee’ can be a label many young people are keen to discard upon settlement in a new society, young people do want practitioners to understand some of the experiences they have faced, such as exposure to violence and persecution, and having to leave behind family and friends in dangerous environments (Valibhoy et al. 2015). Understanding the impact of their refugee experience is important, although the individual details of the trauma may not need to be discussed.

“A trauma centred approach acknowledges that the trauma is in the room, [the need to] work differently with youth with a trauma history, it’s not about having to talk about the trauma” (Colucci et al., 2015). Young people from refugee backgrounds value certain things from practitioners. This includes: advice, support and advocacy to address their needs as they see them, understanding the interrelationship of their practical problems and underlying psychological needs, and a holistic approach that integrates care for both their health and social wellbeing (Valibhoy et al., 2015).

Trust is central to how and whether young people from refugee backgrounds engage with mental health services. Establishing and building trust takes time; many young people have had their sense of trust in others eroded as a result of the refugee experience. Negative experiences with authorities during their migration journey can mean building trust with professionals is a slow process. Explaining how information collected will be used and ensuring confidentiality are integral parts of developing and maintaining trust (Colucci et al., 2015).

Additionally, using interpreters effectively is also important for young people from migrant and refugee backgrounds. Young people should be consulted at the point of referral about their interpreter preferences (for instance, do they prefer a particular gender, language or background?), as young people from small communities may have fears of confidentiality (Colucci et al., 2015). Using phone interpreters or employing bilingual health workers could also assist with ensuring confidentiality.

Using interpreters when necessary, particularly at the point of assessment, is important. This is a critical moment where both the young person and practitioner need to be able to effectively communicate and understand one another. For further information see CALD 4: How to work with interpreters (Waitemata DHB eCALD® services, 2014b).

Engaging with family and community is also an important aspect of supporting young people’s engagement with mental health services. Young people want mental health practitioners to understand the value of family to them and the way this may differ culturally from other client groups. It is important to seek the young person’s input as to if and how they would like a service to work with their family is important.

Advocacy, or holistically attending to the priorities of the young person should also be part of a mental health approach for young people from refugee backgrounds. Meeting young people’s practical needs builds trust and rapport, particularly if they are unfamiliar or hesitant to use mental health services. Best practice for refugee young people requires professionals who are not stuck in their own professional roles, and should work to address immediate needs, which might involve advocacy on the young person’s behalf (Colucci et al., 2015). It is important that mental health services have the flexibility to provide practical support and advocacy for young people and their families. This builds trust and addresses factors that may be compromising their mental wellbeing (CYM, 2015, pp. 7). Practical support may include assisting with family immigration, housing and income support issues.

What sort of guidance can I offer to parents of children/young people experiencing a trauma reaction?

  • Ensure parents have the ability and willingness to support and guide their children and young people.
  • Make use of appropriate services; for example, DHBs’ Child, Adolescent and Family Mental Health Services, RASNZ Centre (Auckland) and Refugee Trauma Recovery (Wellington).
  • Consider advising parents to (Ministry of Health, 2012):
    • Encourage their children/young person to express their emotions.
    • Offer children/ young person support while they are upset.
    • Ask their children questions to find out what they are thinking and imagining.
    • Reassure their children/ young person about the future: the small details of their lives are important and need to be valued.
    • Encourage their children to be children – to play, explore, laugh and do usual things for their age.
    • Maintain routine and predictability, as this helps children/young people to believe that life is secure and predictable.
    • Set caring but definite limits: most children experiencing internal chaos will indicate their need to have clear boundaries set.
    • Minimise change and, when it is necessary, take time to prepare children/ young people for it.
    • Give children/young people feedback about how they are going.
    • Avoid making this the time to correct any bad habits.
    • Avoid over-reacting to difficult behaviour as this may be the child/young person’s way of letting tension out.
    • Give the child/young person time to adjust to a new situation.
    • Make time for just being together (Gordon & Wraith, 1997).